1974
*WILLIAM “BING” D. CONLIN (P)
*GEORGE LEROY POWELL (P)

 1975
*ROBERT A. FRYER (A)
*BOB HOFFMAN (S)
*EARL HUNSICKER (A)

1976
PETE CANIGLIA (P)
LISLE LIGHTER (U)
*HERB SCHOFIELD (U)

1977
ROBERT KENNY (P)
*OSCAR BENSON, SR.  (M)
*WALTER BROOME (M)

1978
*VERDA STEVENS (P)
*JOHN HOSPIDOR (M)

 1979
*VERNE BRANDON (P)
TED BAYNES (M)
JOSEPH J. DRACH (P)
GALEN E. DREIBELBIS (P&S)
*JACK VARDARO (P)
*JIM MANENTI (M)
PA. ARMY NATIONAL GUARD
COMPANY C 867TH ENG BATTALION (S)

1981
*JOE EMBROSKI (P)
*DEAN AMICK (M)
JOE LACOE (U)
*MICHAEL DIETZ (S)

1982
*DAN MILLER (P)
*GEORGE BAUMANN (A)
ROBERT YODER (P)
FRANCIS GRAY (A)

1983
SAM CAIAZZA (P)
*ROBERT KENNESON (U&A)
CLARK MILLER (P)

1984
JOHN ERNEY (P)
*GUY DEMAIO (A)
ROBERT STRAIT (M)
HARRY “CY” YOUNG (C)

1985
GORDIE ECK (P)
ANDREW S. LOECHNER, JR (A)
*JACOB SALSGIVER (U)

1986
AUDREY MCCOMSEY (P)
*J. RICHARD MILLHOUSE (A)
CARL SOLAREK (P)
*PATTI WHITMAN (P) 

1987
AUDREY BETZ (P)
ROCCO SANTILLI (M)
*DORTHY RENEE GREBINGER (P)

1988
GARY DISTASIO (P)
*RANDY KULP (A)
JOE LAROCK (S)
*FRITZ MARTINELLI (S)
FRANK BARLETTA (S)
ROCCO BARLETTA (S)

1989
*ROY HARPSTER (U)
A. BARRIE COLE (A)
DOLORES SEIGFRIED (P)
DYKE ECK (P)
DUDLEY SPORTS COMPANY
- JOE MARSALLA (S)

1990
DAWN KERNS (P)
*JAKE KISLAN (A)
PAUL PRICE (P)

1991
HARRY HUTTON (M)
RICHARD DELONG (P)
SONNY POMPILLI (U)
JOE CARO (U)

1992
PHYLLIS SHAAK (P)
WILLIAM E. ROBISON (A)
DONALD JOHNSON (P)
CHARLES KAUFFMAN (M)
*DONALD RUNYON (U)

1993
MICHAEL KOVACH (P)
ALBERT JONES (A)
*ROBERT W. LILLEY (A)

1994
JAMES “JUNIE” NOEL (U&A)

1995
*RAY SAUL (A)
*STEVE MOORE (P)
CHARLES BREON (U) 

1996
JAMES KAUFFMAN (P)
FRANK MATHEWS (P)
*ROCKEY COLANGELO (S)
BERNIE PROFATO (U)

1997
JUDY HORNING (P)
ROBERT MARTIN (P)
HENRY POLLARD (U)
*EDWARD MCGAUGHEY (A)

 1998
DAVID PERSING  (A)

1999
JOE HURLEY (A)
*LARRY LOSS (U)
*CURT LEMUELL (A)
PAUL KNAPP (M)
RON RHOADS (P)

2000
JOE MATALAVAGE (U)
PAT NATTLE (P)
ANTHONY GUILIANO (P)
JEFF SIPE (P) 

2001
GENE MCSWEENEY (M)
PAUL KOLLAR (P)
DONALD WESTBROOK (P)
RAY OSWALD (U)

2002
TY STOFFLET (P)
ART HOOVER (M)
KENNETH MECKLEY (A)
ELMER DIXON (U)

2003
ROBERT P. “BOB” SAVOIE (U)
JAMES “JIM” DOUGHERTY (P&A)
FRED “BULL” RYAN (P)
HARRY “PINKY” GERACI (P&M) 

2004
ED DULL (P)
*HAL LUTZ (P)
RON HOAK (P)
BARRY SHARP (A)

2005
CHARLES R. RHOADES, SR. (P)
DEGENSTEIN FOUNDATION  (S)
R. LUAU BOWERS (U)
DON E. PORTER (A)

2006
*BERNICE “MOONIE” MOHN (P)
JOHN G. ROKOSZ (A)
ROBERT C. SCOTT (U) 

2007
MIKE SHENK (P)
DALE JOHNSON (P&A)
RONALD C. SCOTT (U)
PAUL YANISKO (U) 

2008
*RONALD BOHNER (A)
THERESA DUNBAR (P)
JAMES HERTZLER (P)
KENNETH HERTZLER (P)
JERRY WAGNER (P)
RON TRIMBLE (A)

2009
*VICTORIA “RONNIE” MAUREK (P&A)
VIRGINIA “GINNY” HEATH (P&A)
THOMAS G. ABER (U)
STACEY H. STUCK (A)

2010
MARY ANN CURRAN (P)
BARRY N. WEAVER (P)
BARRY PARMER, SR. (P)
DAVID ROCCO (P)
READING RISING SUN’S (T)
YORK COUNTY VISITORS BUREAU (S)

2011
STEVE FORNADEL (A)
INEZ “CHICK” LONG (P)
PETER J. ANDRASKO (U)
WILLIAM PENNABAKER (P)
SULLIVAN GELET (A)
JEFFREY KEPNER (P)
YORK CITY & YORK CITY PARKS & RECREATION (S) 

2012
*BARRY L. PARMER, JR. (P)
FRANCIS E. KEATING (P)
IRON DUKES SOFTBALL (T)
JOHN FRANK (P)
*JOHN MCANDREW (P)
MICHAEL WALSH (P)
ROBERT W. MULLANEY (P) 

2013
*CHARLES “JACK” OHL (P)
MICHAEL OHL (P)
RONALD WISSINGER (P)
CHARLES DIMARCO (P)
JEFF SELL (P)
BERNADETTE MURPHY (U)
*TOM SCHADT (S)(A) 

2014
REXFORD DALE GIBERSON (P)
DAN MCCOLLICK (C)(A)
CHARLES “SONNY” TERMINE (P)(S)
*SAMUEL J. RICCARDO, SR. (P)
ED MCCORMICK (S)
MAROADI TRANSFER (T)

2015
*BARRY L. LUTZ (P)
NANCY KEELEY (P)
SHARON HILL WOMEN (T)
DAVID M. BREON (P)
SUZANNE ROBISON (A) 

2016
THOMAS JASONIS, SR. (P)
BARRY L. ALBRIGHT (P)
CLASSIC BEER/FINLEY CATERING (T)     
WILFRED E. “BUD” BRENNEN (A)
ERIE HARD CHROME/RACK N’ ROLL (T)

2017
 STEVE DIMITRY (A/P)
JOSEPH ORGANEK (A)
DELAWARE COUNTY DAILY TIMES (S)

2018
JERE R. FLICK (A/S)
DAN ISAACS (P)
TERRY KREIDER (P)
GERALD RANCK (P)
DONALD “STICKS” STONER (U/A)
EAGLE A.A. FP TEAM (T)

2019
ROBERT REAM (A)
SOUTH LEBANON SOFTBALL (T)
SHIRLEY “MA” PARKER (A)
MICHAEL J. MULL (P)
AL’S COLD CUTS (T)
*THOMAS “JAKE” CAULER (P)
DANIEL SMITH (U)
MARGARET LOECHNER (A) 

2020 
LEE LUTZ (P)
*IRV LUTZ (P)
JIM “THE GENERAL” PATTON (P)
JANN DUCK (A)
*ARNIE WEAVER (P)
GEOFFREY “JEFF” FREY (A)
GARY GABRIEL (A)
SCOTT S. GOLD, II (P)
WARREN L. PIRRING (A)